The United States has always prided itself on classrooms that produce analytical thinkers, problem-solvers, and innovators. Today, that pride is under siege. According to data recently shared by Ohio GOP Governor candidate Vivek Ramaswamy, 78% of 12th graders are not proficient in mathematics, and 65% cannot read at grade level. “This is the hard truth & now it’s up to the states to fix it,” Ramaswamy wrote, turning a spotlight on a national crisis that policymakers have long ignored. The numbers, deemed “unacceptable” by the Department of Labor, expose a system struggling to uphold the very skills that once defined American educational excellence.The story behind the statistics is far more alarming than the figures alone suggest. Literacy and numeracy have been eroding for years, accelerated by technological distractions, fragmented curricula, and persistent societal inequalities. Students today face classrooms that emphasize test preparation over reasoning, bite-sized content over sustained engagement, and standardized benchmarks over intellectual curiosity. The result is a generation increasingly unprepared for the demands of higher education, the workforce, and civic life, a generation that risks inheriting opportunity without the tools to seize it.
The numbers are not fiction
These are not political talking points, they are facts. The Department of Labor called the statistics “unacceptable,” warning that federal bureaucracy is failing American students. Yet, instead of sparking policy action, Ramaswamy was accused of “bashing American students” and even faced attacks linking his commentary to cultural and racial narratives.Critics argue that exceptional students still exist in abundance, particularly in STEM, and that American graduates remain competitive globally. But the data is unforgiving: A generation is systematically losing the basic tools of literacy and numeracy, threatening future economic competitiveness.
Decades of decline
The problem is decades in the making. According to the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), reading proficiency among 12th graders fell from 74% in 2013 to 67% in 2024, while math proficiency dropped from 65% to 55%. The pandemic may have accelerated the decline, but it did not create it.The reality is stark: American students are increasingly unprepared to read critically, reason mathematically, and solve complex problems, skills that were once the hallmark of US education.
A culture of distraction
Experts trace the decline to societal and technological shifts. Today’s students inhabit a world dominated by rapid-fire notifications, social media, and bite-sized content. The stamina for sustained reading and analytical thinking is shrinking.Curricula designed for short-term testing rather than conceptual mastery exacerbate the problem. Math instruction emphasizes procedural fluency over reasoning. Reading assignments focus on snippets rather than long-form engagement. The result: students can follow the steps but struggle to understand the ideas.
Inequality deepens the crisis
Declining proficiency is not uniform. Students from under-resourced schools and lower-income households are hit hardest. Gender disparities in STEM are widening again, as targeted engagement programs for girls disappear. The system, instead of leveling the playing field, is reinforcing inequality, creating a generation ill-equipped for college, careers, or civic life.
The stakes are existential
Ramaswamy’s warnings, political controversies aside, reflect a fundamental truth: America is at risk of losing its intellectual edge. If literacy and numeracy continue to erode, the consequences will ripple through the economy, workforce, and democracy itself.Experts argue that reversing this trend requires deep pedagogical reform: Inquiry-based STEM learning, extended reading assignments, complex problem-solving, and targeted support for underperforming schools. Without decisive action, the next generation may inherit a nation of opportunity but lack the skills to seize it.
The hard truth Americans must confront
This is more than politics. This is a reckoning with a decade-long, systemic decline in the very skills that define intellectual resilience. The question is no longer whether American students are failing; it is whether the nation will act before it loses a generation to avoidable educational decay.
About the Author
